• Home
  • Stories
    • News >
      • 2022 Local Government Elections
    • Learning & Literacy
    • Food, Farming & Fishing >
      • Recipe Collection
    • Culture & Heritage
    • Wellness
    • Environment
    • Opinions, letters and reflections
  • About Us
    • Donate
  • Jobs
    • Job Posting Submission Form
    • Job Postings
  • E-magazine
  • Calendar
  • Albert County
    • Community Directory
    • Churches
    • Living in Albert County
    • Our Villages
    • Attractions
  • Ads
  • Trails
Connecting Albert County

opinions, Letters, ​​and
​reflections
​

Electoral Reform: Single Member-Proportional Vote (aka The Bennett Method)

1/6/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
The Single Member-Proportional Vote (SM-PV) system (aka The Bennett Method after the former Prime Minister from Albert County) has been proposed by James Wilson, a 28-year-old who was born and raised in Albert County. After studying political science, history, and classical political thought at Mount Allison University, he went to Alberta to get work at the end of 2013.
​
Continue to read his story and his proposal for electoral reform.

While working as a night auditor for a Comfort Inn in Fox Creek, Alberta I had a random thought; What if you made MP votes stronger or weaker based on how well they did in the election? Could you make First-past-the-post proportional by doing this?

The first draft of my idea covered two memo pad sheets. While the final name for my system is Single Member-Proportional Vote (SM-PV), its working name for much of the time was the 'Bennett Method,’ named for former Prime Minister R.B. Bennett who was also born and raised in Albert County. I believe as a successful businessman he would have been familiar with the underlying concept of my idea (corporate stockholders have weighted votes based on how many stocks they have). Further I think the Tory Prime Minister would have appreciated an idea for electoral reform that aims to keep as much of the present system intact as is feasible.

After I moved back to New Brunswick at the start of 2015 I had some time to give my idea a re-think. Because my idea didn't modify seat totals or the voting method I was able to use the results of past federal and New Brunswick elections to test out if my idea met its goal of making parliament more proportional.

An early version of my idea also sought to reward MPs who did very well in their ridings.  However, to do this required a series of complex mathematical steps that actually made the results only slightly better than the current setup and didn't give well-performing MPs that much of a boost.

In March 2015, I abandoned the idea of rewarding MPs who get large percentages of the vote allowed me to have results that better reflected the popular vote and weeded out some of the weirder results that popped up in the old system.

The system now only had two goals:
1. Make votes in Parliament be based off of the popular vote rather than seat count, and
2. Keep as much of the current system in place as possible.

As I was attempting to put together my proposal I discovered that I was not the only one looking at this type of system. Stephen Johnson in the UK has been working on a similar idea. I was happy to see I wasn't the only one thinking about this idea and I used his proposal as a loose template for how I organized mine.

Read the detailed proposal  here. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Views from Albert County


    ​Connecting Albert County would like to thank the following supporters & advertisers:

    Platinum supporters
    - Bennett and Albert County Health Care (BACH) Foundation  
    ​- Albert County Pharmacy
    ​​- Hon. Rob Moore, MP for Fundy Royal


    Gold supporters
    - CBDC Westmorland Albert 
    - ​Albert County Funeral Home​​


    Silver supporters
    - 
    Albert County Chamber of Commerce 
    ​ - Foods of the Fundy Valley​
    - Hon. Mike Holland, Minister, MLA-Albert 

     - Fundy Highlands Motel and Chalets

    Bronze supporters
    - ​Chipoudy Communities Revitalization Committee (CCRC)

    - Jeff MacDougall, SouthEastern Mutual Insurance ​
    ​
    If you would like to support Connecting Albert County, visit our Advertising page or Donation page. With your support, we can continue to share the news of rural Albert County.

    Comments
    We welcome comments to our blog postings. Please provide your email address and name with your comment, and respect our content guidelines.

    Archives

    November 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    November 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015

    Categories

    All
    ACOA
    Albert County
    Albert County Chamber Of Commerce
    Albert County NB
    Alma
    Alma Celebration Days
    Bay Of Fundy
    Buy Local
    CCRC
    Chamber Of Commerce
    Childcare
    Childhood
    Children
    Chipoudy Communities Revitalization Committee
    Christmas
    Christmas Shopping
    Collage
    Community
    Community Collaboration
    Community Events
    Community Involvement
    Congratulations
    Construction
    Contribute
    Couchsurfing
    Crooked Creek
    Daycare
    Day Care
    Drivers
    East Coast Kids
    Economy
    Ecosystem
    Education
    Educators
    Elections NB
    Electoral Reform
    Environment
    Espresso Yourself Coffee Break
    Farmers Market
    Frontline Workers
    Fundy
    Fundy Park
    Fundy Shoreline
    Government
    Harvest
    Hillsborough
    History
    Home-made Candles
    Home-made Gifts
    Honourable Mike Holland
    Hopewell Rocks
    Hospitality
    Ideas
    Introduction
    Learning
    Local Service Districts
    Logging
    LSDs
    Marshes
    Memoir
    Moranda Van Geest
    Mystery
    NB
    New Brunswick
    New Coordinator
    Newsletter
    Nominations
    Nuts
    Open Letter
    Opinion
    Poetry
    Protected Area
    Public Library
    Rediscover Main Streets
    Response
    Riverside-Albert
    Riverview Lions Club
    Road
    Road Construction
    Rural Rides
    Salt Marsh
    Save Our Seed
    Seed Campaign
    Share
    Shepody
    Shepody Food Bank
    Shepody Mountain
    Single Member-Proportional Vote
    Southeast Regional Service Commission
    Spring
    Stories
    Submissions
    Summer Students
    Thank You
    The Old Church Farmers Market
    The Order Of New Brunswick
    Tourism
    Update
    Urban Drivers
    Vendors
    Volunteer
    Volunteers
    Warm Showers
    Waterside
    Welcome Committee
    Woodlots

    RSS Feed

CONTACT
ADVERTISING
CALENDAR
PUBLICATION

SiteLock
Copyright © Connecting Albert County, 2021 | Albert County, New Brunswick, Canada
  • Home
  • Stories
    • News >
      • 2022 Local Government Elections
    • Learning & Literacy
    • Food, Farming & Fishing >
      • Recipe Collection
    • Culture & Heritage
    • Wellness
    • Environment
    • Opinions, letters and reflections
  • About Us
    • Donate
  • Jobs
    • Job Posting Submission Form
    • Job Postings
  • E-magazine
  • Calendar
  • Albert County
    • Community Directory
    • Churches
    • Living in Albert County
    • Our Villages
    • Attractions
  • Ads
  • Trails